Boston Pizza vs East Side Mario’s: Prices & Menu Compared (2026)

The short answer

Boston Pizza and East Side Mario’s are both Canadian casual-dining chains, but they are built for different dinners. Boston Pizza is the bigger, broader chain: around 380 locations across Canada, a sports-bar side, and a menu that runs from pizza and pasta to wings, burgers and ribs. East Side Mario’s is the smaller, more Italian-focused chain — about 63 locations, most of them in Ontario — built around pasta, parmigiana and its famous unlimited soup, salad and garlic homeloaf with every main.

On price, the two chains are closer than their reputations suggest. A 10-inch specialty pizza costs roughly the same at both. East Side Mario’s pulls ahead on pasta value, thanks to its endless sides and its Monday and Wednesday deals; Boston Pizza pulls ahead on pizza variety, sports-bar atmosphere and the sheer number of locations. Which one is better value depends on what your table actually orders — and this guide compares them dish by dish so you can decide before you sit down.

At a glance

Boston PizzaEast Side Mario’s
Locations in Canada~380, coast to coast~63, mostly Ontario (~48 there)
What it isFamily restaurant + sports barItalian-American casual dining
Pizza sizesIndividual 8″, Small 10″, Medium 13″, Large 15″10″ and 14″ (plus calzones)
PastaWide range, plus gluten-free optionsThe heart of the menu
Signature valuePasta Tuesday, Wing Wednesday, $15 lunchUnlimited soup, salad & garlic homeloaf with mains
KidsChildren’s menu + Kids CardMini Marios kids menu
LoyaltyMyBP rewardsNone widely advertised — check with your location
Best forGame nights, mixed tastes, big groupsPasta lovers, family dinners, Ontario diners

Pizza prices compared

Pizza is where the two chains overlap most directly, and it is also where a straight price comparison can mislead: the chains do not sell the same sizes. Boston Pizza’s large is 15 inches; East Side Mario’s largest pizza is 14 inches. Comparing a 15-inch pie with a 14-inch pie without adjusting for size flatters the smaller one.

Reference prices below come from published Canadian menus in late 2026. Both chains set prices at the restaurant level, so your location may differ — treat these as a guide, not a guarantee.

PizzaBoston PizzaEast Side Mario’s
Small specialty pizza (10″)~$19.99–$20.99~$16.99–$20.18
Medium specialty pizza (13″)~$28.99–$29.49— (no 13″ size)
Large specialty pizza (15″ BP / 14″ ESM)~$34.49–$35.29~$24.99–$29.69
Create-your-own, large~$25.99~$22.99 (14″)
Cauliflower crust (10″)Available, price varies~$17.99–$20.98
CalzoneNot a menu staple~$17.49–$21.37

Two things stand out. First, at the 10-inch size the chains are effectively tied — East Side Mario’s is cheaper at the low end of the range, Boston Pizza sits in the same band at the top end. Second, the large-pizza gap is mostly a size gap: Boston Pizza’s 15-inch pie covers about 177 square inches against about 154 for a 14-inch pie, so the roughly $5–$10 difference buys real extra pizza. On a per-square-inch basis, Boston Pizza’s large create-your-own (about $25.99 for ~177 square inches) is among the cheapest ways to feed a group at either chain.

Boston Pizza also wins on pizza variety: more specialty pizzas, four sizes, and a cauliflower crust option. East Side Mario’s keeps its pizza list short — five specialty pizzas, two sizes — and puts its energy into pasta instead. Our Boston Pizza pizza sizes guide explains what each Boston Pizza size serves if you are planning for a group.

Pasta prices compared

Pasta is East Side Mario’s home ground, and it shows in both the menu and the value. Dinner pastas at East Side Mario’s typically run about $21.49–$26.99, with signature dishes such as the Balsamic Mushroom Alfredo and the Big Baked Trio at the top of that range. Crucially, most mains come with unlimited soup, salad and garlic homeloaf — so a $24 pasta at East Side Mario’s is a three-part meal, not a plate on its own.

Boston Pizza’s pasta mains sit in a similar band, roughly the low-to-mid $20s depending on the dish and location, and its pasta range is wider — from classic Alfredo-style dishes to Jambalaya Fettuccine. But Boston Pizza does not bundle unlimited sides with its mains, so a straight dish-to-dish price comparison understates the East Side Mario’s value.

The sharpest pasta deal in this comparison is East Side Mario’s lunch menu: many of the same pastas that cost $21.49–$22.49 at dinner are about $13.99 at lunch. Boston Pizza’s answer is its lunch deal — a roughly $15 lunch with a 20-minute guarantee — which our Boston Pizza lunch guarantee guide explains in full. For a weekday lunch, both chains are genuinely cheap; for a dinner pasta, East Side Mario’s usually gives you more food for the money.

Parmigiana, mains and everything else

East Side Mario’s signature main is Mario’s Chicken Parmigiana, about $25.49–$27.49, with veal and triple-threat versions in the same band. Boston Pizza has no direct equivalent — its mains lean towards burgers (around $17–$19), ribs and chicken sandwiches rather than Italian parmigiana. If parmigiana is what you want, East Side Mario’s is the only one of the two that serves it properly.

The reverse is true for everything beyond pasta and pizza. Boston Pizza’s menu is far broader: wings (including the Wing Wednesday deal), burgers, ribs, salads, sandwiches and a full sports-bar appetizer list. East Side Mario’s menu is narrower and more focused — starters, pasta, pizza, parmigiana, sandwiches and desserts, with the garlic homeloaf doing a lot of the heavy lifting. A table where one person wants a burger and another wants pasta will be happier at Boston Pizza; a table where everyone wants Italian will be happier at East Side Mario’s.

Deals and loyalty: who saves you more

This is where the comparison gets interesting, because the two chains discount in completely different ways.

Boston Pizza deals:

  • Pasta Tuesday — a weekly pasta deal, one of the chain’s best-known value nights.
  • Wing Wednesday — 50% off wings, explained in our Wing Wednesday guide.
  • Lunch deal — roughly $15 with a 20-minute guarantee, or your next lunch free.
  • MyBP rewards — points on every visit, redeemable for food.

East Side Mario’s deals:

  • Monday — $10 for a 10-inch specialty pizza (with a beverage purchase).
  • Wednesday — all-you-can-eat pasta for $19.99, including unlimited soup, salad and garlic homeloaf, dine-in only.
  • Thursday — Amore for Two, a $50 three-course Italian feast for two.
  • Every day — unlimited soup, salad and garlic homeloaf with every main, dine-in.

East Side Mario’s deals are stronger for a sit-down dinner: the Monday $10 pizza and Wednesday $19.99 all-you-can-eat pasta are hard to beat. Boston Pizza’s deals are stronger across the week — Wing Wednesday and Pasta Tuesday cover two different cravings, and MyBP points accumulate on every visit rather than only on deal nights. If you eat at one chain regularly, MyBP tips the long-term maths towards Boston Pizza; if you are picking a single night out, East Side Mario’s deal nights are the better bargain.

Family meals and feeding a crowd

For families, East Side Mario’s bundles are the standout. The Famiglia Pizza Combo (serves 2–4) runs about $35–$42, the Family Pasta Deal (serves 4) about $43–$55, and the Group Meal (serves 6–8) about $60–$75, depending on location and source. Those bundles include the unlimited sides for dine-in, which makes them very hard to beat per person.

Boston Pizza does not sell the same kind of fixed family bundle nationally. Its group-feeding strategy is build-your-own: large pizzas plus wings and sharing plates, with deals such as Pasta Tuesday and Wing Wednesday doing the discounting. For a group of 10 or more, Boston Pizza’s bigger dining rooms and sports-bar space are usually the easier fit — our Boston Pizza group booking guide explains how large parties work there — while East Side Mario’s smaller rooms suit a family table better than a team dinner.

Kids, atmosphere and locations

Kids: Both chains welcome children. Boston Pizza has a children’s menu and the Kids Card — a $5 donation that earns five free kids meals, explained in our Kids Card guide. East Side Mario’s has the Mini Marios kids menu, including a kids build-your-own pasta at about $8.99–$10.68.

Atmosphere: Boston Pizza is half sports bar — big screens, game nights, a louder room. East Side Mario’s is a warmer, more traditional Italian-American dining room, quieter and more focused on the meal. For a hockey night, Boston Pizza wins; for a relaxed family dinner, East Side Mario’s does.

Locations: This is the most practical difference. Boston Pizza has roughly 380 locations across Canada, so there is almost always one nearby. East Side Mario’s has about 63, with roughly 48 in Ontario — if you live outside Ontario, your nearest East Side Mario’s may be a drive away. Check with your location before travelling for a deal night.

The verdict: which chain should you choose?

  • Choose Boston Pizza if: you want pizza variety and bigger sizes, a sports-bar atmosphere for a game, wings or burgers alongside the Italian dishes, MyBP rewards on every visit, or a location near you anywhere in Canada.
  • Choose East Side Mario’s if: pasta is the main event, you want the unlimited soup, salad and garlic homeloaf, you are feeding a family on a bundle, or it is a Monday or Wednesday deal night.
  • Choose either for: a 10-inch pizza — the price is effectively the same, so pick the toppings and the room you prefer.

Neither chain is the cheap option across the board. Boston Pizza wins on breadth, locations and pizza size; East Side Mario’s wins on pasta value and family bundles. The best value dinner at either chain is a deal night — and the best way to waste money at either is to order at full price on a Friday without checking what that night’s offer is.

How we verified this guide

No dedicated Boston Pizza vs East Side Mario’s comparison was found in search results — the top results were separate menu-price lists for each chain, with no head-to-head article. Prices in this guide are reference prices drawn from the chains’ published Canadian menus and menu-price listings from October–November 2026, cross-checked where sources disagreed and presented as ranges where they did. Both chains set prices at the restaurant level, so figures vary by location and change over time. Where a policy or price could not be verified, this guide says so instead of inventing a number.

Disclaimer: Prices, deals and menu items vary by location and change over time. East Side Mario’s deal nights and Boston Pizza’s weekly deals may differ at your restaurant — confirm the current offer with your location before you go.

Frequently asked questions

Is East Side Mario’s cheaper than Boston Pizza?

At the 10-inch pizza size, the two are effectively tied. East Side Mario’s is usually cheaper for pasta dinners, thanks to unlimited soup, salad and garlic homeloaf with every main, while Boston Pizza’s large 15-inch pizzas offer better value per square inch.

Which has better pizza, Boston Pizza or East Side Mario’s?

Boston Pizza has more pizza variety and four sizes up to 15 inches. East Side Mario’s keeps a short list of five specialty pizzas in 10-inch and 14-inch sizes. For pizza-first dinners, Boston Pizza offers more choice; for a simple, well-made specialty pizza, either works.

Does East Side Mario’s have unlimited bread?

East Side Mario’s serves unlimited soup, salad and garlic homeloaf with most mains when you dine in. It is the chain’s signature value feature and the main reason its pasta dinners stretch further than Boston Pizza’s.

What is East Side Mario’s $10 pizza deal?

On Mondays, East Side Mario’s offers a 10-inch specialty pizza for $10 with a beverage purchase, dine-in. The offer covers the five specialty pizzas — Hawaiian Heat, Loaded Pepperoni, Four Meat, The Ultimate Canadian and Balsamic Pesto. Confirm it with your location, as deals vary.

Does Boston Pizza have a loyalty program?

Yes — MyBP earns points on every visit, redeemable for food. East Side Mario’s does not run a widely advertised equivalent rewards program, so regular Boston Pizza visitors get more long-term value from loyalty points.

Which chain is better for a family dinner?

East Side Mario’s family bundles (Famiglia Pizza Combo for 2–4, Family Pasta Deal for 4, Group Meal for 6–8) are usually the better per-person deal for a family, especially with the unlimited sides. Boston Pizza is the better choice for a larger group or a mixed-taste table, thanks to its bigger rooms and broader menu.